Halloween rules target sex offenders. Do they protect kids? [Interview with Janice]

Source: usatoday.com 10/29/2026
[ACSOL note: scroll down to see Janice’s interview in bold]

By N’dea Yancey-Bragg

As Halloween approaches, law enforcement agencies across the country are reviving a controversial yet common plan to keep children safe. In many cities and states, certain sex offenders will be barred from handing out candy, decorating their homes or even having their lights on while families are out trick-or-treating. In some areas, hundreds of officers will go door to door to ensure compliance while in others, offenders are required to spend the evening at the local police station. Some of these restrictions have faced successful legal challenges from offenders who say they impose on their constitutional rights.

Advocates for offenders and experts on child sex crimes say the restrictions are a solution in search of a problem. Elizabeth J. Letourneau, director of the Moore Center for the Prevention of Child Sexual Abuse at the Johns Hopkins University, compared the idea of children being lured in and assaulted by sex offenders on Halloween to the myth of tainted Halloween candy. “This is not actually doing anything to keep kids safe and it’s a distraction from things that we should be putting our time and resources into,” Letourneau said. Some law enforcement officials behind the practice agree the actual risk to trick-or-treaters is low. But some say the restrictions, which they have been enforcing for decades, remain an important step to show the community and the offenders that they take children’s safety seriously.

“It also helps us to be able to talk about just overall Halloween safety,” said Grace Knutson, director of sex offender programs at the Wisconsin Department of Corrections. “This is a difficult time because all the rest of the year we tell children not to take candy from strangers and at Halloween, it is essentially what they end up doing.”

From lock-ins to pumpkin bans: What sex offenders can’t do on Halloween Knutson said there are 28,000 people on Wisconsin’s sex offender registry but only 6,000 of those registrants face special restrictions on Halloween. They can’t wear costumes and must remain indoors for one hour before and one hour after locally scheduled trick-or-treating times, she said. They also can’t have any decorations, a bowl of candy or even porch lights on outside their home.

Probation and parole agents team up with local law enforcement all over the state to check their homes to ensure compliance, Knutson said. Planning for the operation begins in August each year, and hundreds of officials aim to conduct between 2,000 and 2,500 home visits, focusing on offenders who have been convicted of crimes against children. In 2025, there were 136 violations found during the sweep, Knutson said. Punishments can vary, ranging from being taken into custody to simply facing increased probation or parole restrictions.

“A lot of times it has to do with the registrant is living with somebody else, say an elderly family member, and that family member forgets or doesn’t realize that that person maybe can’t have pumpkins sitting outside,” Knutson said of the kinds of violations law enforcement typically encounters. While violations are relatively rare, the risk to trick-or-treaters is rarer still. One example Knutson said is often mentioned is the case of Gerald Turner, who abducted and killed 9-year-old Lisa Ann French on Halloween night in 1973 while she was trick-or-treating in Fond du Lac, Wisconsin. Turner is currently seeking release from state custody, and a jury trial for commitment proceedings is scheduled to begin in January.

“The victimization of Lisa French in that case that I mentioned is absolutely horrific, very, very traumatic for the community as a whole, as well as the family,” she said. “But I will tell you that that is the one and only.” Knutson stressed the home visits on Halloween were not sparked by French’s murder.

Law enforcement has been conducting such compliance checks for about 18 years, she said, and officials primarily use the moment to educate the community about pedestrian safety, which is a much bigger issue for kids on Halloween. Still, she said the home visits are worth the effort. “I think it’s just our way of our department, division of community corrections, to show the public that we are doing everything we can to keep the community safe,” Knutson said. “We also want to send a message to the registrants that we put these restrictions on you and with that, we obviously mean that we will follow up with making sure that you’re following those restrictions as well.”

California’s annual Halloween sweep, known as Operation Boo, is even older, stretching back three and a half decades, according to Bryan Bishop, director of the state’s Division of Adult Parole Operations. In 2025, 300 parole agents helped check the homes of registered sex offenders who were on “active parole status,” Bishop said. “This year’s (Halloween is) on a Saturday night so it’s really difficult to get staff to participate when they have their own children and functions they want to attend,” he said. California’s restrictions are similar to Wisconsin’s but last even longer, from 5 p.m. on Halloween to 5 a.m. the following morning. Bishop said the rules have a “really high compliance rate,” noting that Operation Boo resulted in just 35 arrests in 2025. “As a parent myself and as a grandparent, I take this operation very personal,” he said. “I want to protect our kids and I want to make sure our kids are aware of the risks when they’re out in the community, often times unattended.”

In some areas, local restrictions go even further than state requirements. Georgia has statewide requirements for sex offenders similar to Wisconsin and California, according to the state’s Department of Community Supervision. But in Effingham County, Sheriff Jimmy McDuffie has required every registered sex offender that is on probation to spend Halloween at his office for his nearly 25-year tenure, according to public information officer Brian Bailey. Though Bailey said he was not aware of any incidents in which local trick-or-treaters were targeted, he said the tradition provides peace of mind for both families and offenders. If a crime does occur, he explained, “no one can blame it on them because they’re here at the office.” Do these rules work? Measures face questions, legal challenges A 2009 study of more than 67,000 sex offenses reported to law enforcement agencies in 30 states across nine years “found no significant increase in risk for nonfamilial child sexual abuse on or just prior to Halloween.”

Researchers determined sex crimes against children of this kind represented less than 0.2% of all Halloween incidents with theft, vandalism, assault and burglary being far more common. “It was precisely what we expected, that generally speaking when kids are in more highly supervised situations, they’re at much lower risk for sexual harm,” said study co-author Letourneau. Letourneau said the laws restricting sex offender participation in Halloween activities likely stem from two popular misconceptions: that children are most at risk of sexual violence from strangers and that people who commit such crimes are highly likely to reoffend. Those risks exist, including on Halloween, but she said a sex offender targeting a trick-or-treater “would be a very rare thing.” “It’s vanishingly unlikely that this scenario plays out,” she said. “Kind of like the razors in apples thing.” In addition to questions about the efficacy, some of the restrictions on sex offenders’ behavior on Halloween have faced legal challenges.

The issue came back into the national spotlight most recently when Thomas Sanderson, who was convicted of a sex offense in 2006, challenged a Missouri law that required offenders to post signs stating “No candy or treats at this residence” on their homes. Sanderson, who regularly created elaborate Halloween displays, was prosecuted for violating the rules in 2022 after a neighbor complained, according to his attorney Janice Bellucci. Bellucci, the executive director of The Alliance for Constitutional Sex Offense Laws, filed a lawsuit on Sanderson’s behalf, arguing the sign requirement violates free speech protections. The state countered that the signs protect children. A federal judge ruled against Missouri and an appeals court affirmed that decision, saying there’s no evidence that children would be at risk without such postings, as long as the registered sex offender complies with the state’s other Halloween rules. Those include leaving the lights off, remaining inside and not engaging with trick-or-treaters.

The U.S. Supreme Court on Oct. 19 declined to get involved, over the objection of Justice Samuel Alito. Bellucci said Sanderson was “relieved” that the case had come to an end and would no longer create the displays. Similar lawsuits over required signage have had success in a Simi Valley, California case handled by Bellucci as well as in Jacksonville, Florida and Butts County, Georgia, according to court records.

“Because there’s now a precedential opinion from the Eleventh Circuit, I don’t think any county in Georgia or Florida or Alabama for that matter would engage in the practice at this point,” said Mark Yurachek, the attorney who represented the offenders in the Georgia case. But such requirements persist in other states including Texas and Bellucci said she’s looking to file more challenges against them. “They’re absolutely not necessary…this Missouri state law and all the other laws that require Halloween signs are really a solution without a problem,” she said.

Contributing: Maureen Groppe, USA TODAY; Daphne Lemke, Fond du Lac Reporter

Read the original article
[Requires a subscription]

 

Related posts

Subscribe
Notify of

If you are feeling extremely depressed and possibly even suicidal, please call or text 988 (suicide hotline) or any loved one who you believe is immediately available. If you feel depressed and in need of a friendly community and unbiased emotional support, you can email Alex and Marty at emotionalsupportgroup@all4consolaws.org

 

We welcome a lively discussion with all view points - keeping in mind...

  1. Submissions must be in English
  2. Your submission will be reviewed by one of our volunteer moderators. Moderating decisions may be subjective.
  3. Please keep the tone of your comment civil and courteous. This is a public forum.
  4. Swear words should be starred out such as f*k and s*t and a**
  5. Please avoid the use of derogatory labels.  Always use person-first language.
  6. Please stay on topic - both in terms of the organization in general and this post in particular.
  7. Please refrain from general political statements in (dis)favor of one of the major parties or their representatives.
  8. Please take personal conversations off this forum.
  9. We will not publish any comments advocating for violent or any illegal action.
  10. We cannot connect participants privately - feel free to leave your contact info here. You may want to create a new / free, readily available email address that are not personally identifiable.
  11. Please refrain from copying and pasting repetitive and lengthy amounts of text.
  12. Please do not post in all Caps.
  13. If you wish to link to a serious and relevant media article, legitimate advocacy group or other pertinent web site / document, please provide the full link. No abbreviated / obfuscated links. Posts that include a URL may take considerably longer to be approved.
  14. We suggest to compose lengthy comments in a desktop text editor and copy and paste them into the comment form
  15. We will not publish any posts containing any names not mentioned in the original article.
  16. Please choose a short user name that does not contain links to other web sites or identify real people.  Do not use your real name.
  17. Please do not solicit funds
  18. No discussions about weapons
  19. If you use any abbreviation such as Failure To Register (FTR), Person Forced to Register (PFR) or any others, the first time you use it in a thread, please expand it for new people to better understand.
  20. All commenters are required to provide a real email address where we can contact them.  It will not be displayed on the site.
  21. Please send any input regarding moderation or other website issues via email to moderator [at] all4consolaws [dot] org
  22. We no longer post articles about arrests or accusations, only selected convictions. If your comment contains a link to an arrest or accusation article we will not approve your comment.
  23. If addressing another commenter, please address them by exactly their full display name, do not modify or abbreviate their name. 
  24. Please check for typos, spelling, punctuation, and grammar errors before submitting.  Comments that have many errors will not be approved. 
ACSOL, including but not limited to its board members and agents, does not provide legal advice on this website.  In addition, ACSOL warns that those who provide comments on this website may or may not be legal professionals on whose advice one can reasonably rely.  
 

14 Comments

I couldn’t read the article unless my eyes were frightened by what I’d read. Looks like the Knusten with the cheesehead police likes to talk out of both sides of her mouth, so it looks like my eyes dodged a bullet. Wisconsin the land of cheeseheads holding cow pies 24/7.

So the sheriff mandates that registrants (not parolees) go to his office and are confined..err I mean hanging out during Halloween. Sure . That doesn’t sound like punishment at all. It’s just regulatory confinement.

When I was on probation, we had to go to the probation office and sit there all evening. The freaking probation supervisor LOVED to bring the local TV station reporters to show how they were “protecting” the community.

C O N G T A D U L A T I ONS JANICE & TEAM, Other State wins but…USATODAY!
Laws a d US and State constitutions win

Now, if they would only channel and put THIS much energy into keeping keeping kids from getting shot up in the classrooms. But no, gotta go for the easy win by focusing on the non-existent “predator panic” mundane nonsense instead! Are we “great” yet?

A solution with a problem that carries severe consequences for the ones that require the signs to be posted. No one cares or realizes that dangers of posting something outside your home let alone being forced to post your address online. If I have to post my address online I believe politicians should. It’s a safety thing isn’t it? Maybe I want to stay away from that politician? You know the dui and domestic assault they get by with due to immunities? Safety reasons….words…. health and safety. I get the goal but at the same time some of us as myself do not pose a real threat. So blaming all and not the select few is definately not fair. Ive gotten to where i hate halloween because of what happened to me. Ive not been involved in my nieces lives because of it. I could have influenced them to be better people. It bugs me every day. My case is riddled with false things. No major indicators from the past if i could ever explain myself and if you would get to know me on a more personal level will hopefully realize I was never the real issue to begin with. It’s the law enforcement personel thats the real issue. I had my privacy invaded. What got me convicted was childish and the state will not allow any room for legal review. Ive tried everything since my release. And even if they did grant me a win they could turn back around and reconvict me as if I was never convicted to begin with. I get sheriff’s offices do alot and go through alot especially the week of. And their paranoia and anxiety wells up to the moment of. Nobody talks about that? If you’re focused on safety correct? Maybe have night patrol where the cops get out and walk like they did in the old days. Get some exercise instead sitting in their cars wasting gas and eating donuts and coffee looking at their phone while they pretend to ‘observe’ the public at the expense of tax dollars. The public is not an infinite bank account to pull taxes from. Actually interact with the public and maybe brainwash them back into trusting them since theyve become so authoritarian in recent times. What happened to d.a.r.e. cars posting up af major events? Maybe have cops walk in designated neighborhoods that night? The parents are supposed to supervise their kids anyways as heartless as that sounds. If im lucky enough to have a family of my own day(registry restricts alot of that from happening fyi) and what happened to the family in wisconsin… trust me id find a way… This holiday has had so much fear in the past from evil people and even pranksters that it’s led to multiple stigma. Why do we still have distance restrictions if we have school resource officers to prevent all that? More cops in cities. My city used to have maybe 20 cops on a good day… they have over 50 now and that’s an increase with the past 2 years. As well as new cars and equipment.. More and more tax money. The economy is broke. We ALL need a break. The whole population. Leave the stigma at the door and solve real world issues instead of being tricked and manipulated by corrupt and greedy politicians and Tricksters, and fear mongers, and liars… oh wait that sums up the average politician…the registry was supposed to be reserved for the worst of the worst. Some on the registry simply because of an accusation. How is it fair just because of an accusation they end up ruining their lives because of the consequences from being labeled and put on the registry? Then you have politicians and law enforcement that commit a serious crime and resign and slapped on the wrist that never end up on the registry. How is it a fair system? Then you have some out there that quite honestly need to be supervised every day that are very questionable. See the double standards here? None of the program makes sense. Costs too much money. Each state varies in cost whether it be real cost or people pocketing money. Waste of time for most that are on there and law enforcement. They could spend less time watching someone like me with my record and worry more about someone that is 100x more questionable. Politicians have turned into nothing more than corrupted children that have become overwhelmed with greed in some form. Mind you greed and gluttony are a sin. One more point I want to make. Before Michigan was nice enough to remove some from the registry, whatever their reasons. Why is it that kentuckys registry costs over $6mil -$8mil and continues to increase and yet has a less populace than what Michigan had before the removal when Michigan STILL had less population on the registry and it only cost them $1.2 mil?! Why is that?…halloween is a day of jokesters, and tricksters, and theives. Distracting ones attention from a more important matter can quite literally spell life or death for someone that actually needs the help. If 2 come out to do their compliance checks where I live. That’s atleast a 20 minute drive one way going out of their way when in reality most of your danger is in going to be in town or drunk drivers. And those 2 may only spend enough time just too look long enough to see me and get back in their car after a mark on their sheet and a simple wave. In my reality I worry more about corrupt politicians and law enforcement and people drinking and driving and on their phones. I believe the ‘brotherhood’ gang needs to take a more proactive fatherly role instead of the ‘I am the punisher and the alpha and omega’ attitude.

This morning, our ride share driver said he watched another driver take on a light pole and lose on Halloween night. Gathering PFRs and confining them for the night illegally prevented this how?

Last edited 16 days ago by TS

I posted a link to this on every single local police department post about how they were doing compliance checks and keeping kids safe. NOT ONE RESPONSE. That tells me one thing. It made people think about an unpopular side of this.