TX: Condo Association Fighting To Keep Sex Offender Out

A battle between a sex offender in Austin and a home owner’s association could set a precedent across the state if not the country. The association’s decision to ban sex offenders is now being challenged. A sleepy little community in South Austin is fighting what could be a major case.

“I don’t know why this law firm has decided to mount a crusade in favor of pedophiles, but they have,” says Eleanor Rotthoff, a resident of Valley View Village Condominiums The condominium complex voted and amended their homeowner’s association bylaws.

The amendment basically denies residence to anyone required to register as a sex offender. Full Article (with video)

Related posts

Notify of

We welcome a lively discussion with all view points - keeping in mind...


  1. Your submission will be reviewed by one of our volunteer moderators. Moderating decisions may be subjective.
  2. Please keep the tone of your comment civil and courteous. This is a public forum.
  3. Swear words should be starred out such as f*k and s*t
  4. Please stay on topic - both in terms of the organization in general and this post in particular.
  5. Please refrain from general political statements in (dis)favor of one of the major parties or their representatives.
  6. Please take personal conversations off this forum.
  7. We will not publish any comments advocating for violent or any illegal action.
  8. We cannot connect participants privately - feel free to leave your contact info here. You may want to create a new / free, readily available email address.
  9. Please refrain from copying and pasting repetitive and lengthy amounts of text.
  10. Please do not post in all Caps.
  11. If you wish to link to a serious and relevant media article, legitimate advocacy group or other pertinent web site / document, please provide the full link. No abbreviated / obfuscated links. Posts that include a URL may take considerably longer to be approved.
  12. We suggest to compose lengthy comments in a desktop text editor and copy and paste them into the comment form
  13. We will not publish any posts containing any names not mentioned in the original article.
  14. Please choose a short user name that does not contain links to other web sites or identify real people
  15. Please do not solicit funds
  16. If you use any abbreviation such as Failure To Register (FTR), or any others, the first time you use it please expand it for new people to better understand.
  17. All commenters are required to provide a real email address where we can contact them.  It will not be displayed on the site.
  18. Please send any input regarding moderation or other website issues via email to moderator [at] all4consolaws [dot] org
  19. We no longer post articles about arrests or accusations, only selected convictions. If your comment contains a link to an arrest or accusation article we will not approve your comment.
ACSOL, including but not limited to its board members and agents, does not provide legal advice on this website.  In addition, ACSOL warns that those who provide comments on this website may or may not be legal professionals on whose advice one can reasonably rely.  

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Interesting. I don’t know if anyone else recalls, but as early as about 6 or 7 years ago there were a couple developers (best recollection Texas and Georgia) who were promoting their new housing projects as “sex offender-free,” that registrants were not allowed to buy a home or live there, and all buyers would agree if they purchased a home there and were subsequently convicted of a sex related offense they would forfeit their home.

I’m torn on this issue with respect to those private developments. I mean, if a group of people want to purchase homes and live in their own little compound and keep out certain outsiders, then that should be their right. But when everybody starts doing that, where are the “outcasts” supposed to live?

However, the homeowners’ association featured in this article has crossed a line and I think it opens a much larger can of worms pertaining to CC&R overall as a matter of law than just the issue of banning registrants.

Sure thing, just let them try and make it a Jewish, black or ‘minority” free all white community…think that would fly? NO! But they will probably keep those with a sex offense conviction in their PAST out because “sex offenders” are the new black…so to speak!

A so called “sex offense” is the only monitory in the USA that it is perfectly legal to step all over, deny basic services to and otherwise abuse without a second thought.

What happened to giving someone a second chance once they have paid their dept to society, jumped through all the hops, and did everything required of them to do?

Yep, they will probably prevail in keeping the “pervert” out of their perfect white picket fenced wonderland of wholesomeness.

Anyone there now in texas that can give us some more ‘on the front lines’ (so to speak) info on that matter….appreciate it someone from texas………..clearly its further punishment on the restriction ……they are proving the registry is further punishment / inciting discrimination / inciting harassment / inciting violence to people who are forced to register …… or be jailed imprisonment …………looks like extortion / blackmail………forced to incriminate yourself.

Force you to registry or be jailed imprisoned (coercion against your will extortion blackmail)………so as to put you in double jeopardy of punishment restrictions……..their greed to double jeopardy is the current event there in texas……..taxpayer funded registry and its used against the registered to further punishment restrictions violating the Constitution against self incrimination …..its time for BIG $$$$$ lawsuits and I want my name on those checks…!!!

Too bad we’re not independently wealthy; go buy a few of their prized condos and rent them out to thugs, gangsta types and all around low lifes. That would be quite the hoot I’d say…and make sure there’s a variety of colors.

My husband is a no risk level sex offender. We live in a private owned condo. The landlord know his background but accepted is to rent. We have lived here almost 4 years. The HOA board president went door to door warning everyone about him. Whatever. But a few months ago, a tier 3 offender moved in and they made his landlord kick him out after just a few days. The same time the board started putting flyers up EVERYWHERE about my husband. And I mean everywhere! They were thrown all over the complex. Even at the private pool. Even posted 10ft up in a tree. We have no idea why they started doing this and it scares me. My neighbors feel sorry for us and know he is not a monster. We work and come home. We don’t bother anyone. Legally, they cannot force us out. He has no restrictions and the police do not have to send out fliers about him as he has no risk level. Why won’t they just let us alone? We just want to live in peace. I worry about someone shooting at us or our windows. However, the his has decided to monitor the parking lot with cameras for security…. But the only thing the cameras can see is our house!

Not too much better in California. Thought it worst living in the country, were there were a bunch of ignorant hicks. No better in the city where people are on top of each other and gated communities keep undesirable outsiders away. Arrested what seems like ages ago. Plead guilty. Psychological report says I was low risk, recommended leniency. Felt good about myself. Recognized my flaws. Got treated for depression, which I didn’t know I had. Quit alcohol. Got good reports on my offender treatment. Wanted to be open with everyone. Help those who could benefit from my experience. Naivety. Lost a good paying job with benefits, but managed to just support my family by being self employed. Threatened by someone in jail who knew of my offense. Wife couldn’t get a job as a teacher, because someone knew of my offense. In debt, because of lawyers fees, loss of job. No healthcare, but managed to keep up my treatment. At that time I was an anonymous pin on a map. If someone was concerned about me, they could go to the police department and inquire. But I would not give them any concern, because I did what was needed to not offend and get on with my life. I didn’t want to to hurt anyone, let alone my family, who took me in and suffered through the ordeal. Rebuilding a life is tough, but it gives you a sense of accomplishment. Then 9-11 and everyone was afraid. Then two high profile murders in my region and I had vigilantes parked on my street. A truck parked for two days there and scared my daughter. My name appeared in the local paper with other registrants. Now, everyone I do work for could look me up as a “sex offender”. Fliers appeared around the neighborhood. What had I done differently, I asked? I register every year, work, try to have a life. I feel responsible for what I had put my family through and wonder if it would have been better if I had left. I am not so anxious to leave the house anymore or go for a walk where I can meet a neighbor who looks the other way. I wonder if I step in this park, that library, would I be arrested? Everywhere I go I think “they know”, they see the “S” on my record. It’s as plain as my forehead. Every word, measured, every act scrutinized. My wife knows that the family is strong. Stronger than hate or fear. Even after all she’s been through. It’s not only about recidivism and rebuilding a life. It is about survival. Of sanity. Of dignity. About not letting them win. If you let them win your humanity sickens and dies. If you let them win you legitimize the Stasi, the SS, the Red Guard.

I have never been with anyone with a criminal background. I have never been thru this before. The hoa called his work and told them they hired a child rapist predator and that they should fire him. His work told the caller to buzz off. My husband has no restrictions and was charge with lewd conduct. He is not a predator. Someone took a wooden sign, posted it ten feet up in a tree. Someone else came along and took it down hours later and the hoa thinks I took it down. I didn’t touch it. Note they are sending a fine to our landlord. I was told today that the hoa board all voted to have us removed. I have looked up our rights as tenants and the hoa cannot legally force us out our force our landlord to evict us. Luckily the landlord is on our side. Today, another sign was put 10ft up in a tree. I can’t sleep for being scared. Why all the sudden have they started doing this to us after being here so long? The sad thing is, I feel helpless as I can’t help him. This will never ever go away for him. My only choices are too stay with him and be scared or leave him and miss him terribly. He is such a good man with 1 black cloud over him. I am so sad and scared for us both.

Take pictures….make a police report at least its in file…..
registry incites violence…incites threats…disturbs the peace….incites destruction of property ….incites others
to crime and public safety becomes worse because of registry.

tired of being scared, I hope it works out. People who take in ex offenders, also keep them honest and give them something to live for, which studies have shown reduces crime. It saddens me that you have had the choice made so much harder by vigilantes. You should be given a medal by the Governor, for helping to keep society safe. When I came back home, my wife had me paint the front door red. In the early 1800’s the red door was a sign for escaped slaves to find safe house and a secure path to freedom. They took the risk of being punished for doing that. A lot of people then would have had no hope at all without them.

Well, now the HOA have upped the stakes. My car was parked in our assigned and numbered parking spot. Someone keyed it. Since the huge yellow sign is still in the tree and we are not allowed to take it down, the culprit gets to see it, associates my car that he doesn’t drive, vandalizes it and now I get to pay for it? He is barely making any money because he cab only find lame jobs, what an I supposed to do? Throw him away? Everyone seems to get on their soap boxes and tell that WE cannot judge another. Well, they are judging and cruelly doing so. And March 1st is The day we can no longer go to the local park to bbq as SO’s are no longer allowed in because they think all of them are going to snatch kids and hurt them.

A registered Sex offender myself, despite following the law to the letter, I have had a very hard time with jobs and finding places to live for my family. I committed my crime in 1997, a Christian and law abiding person. I no longer have to register in my conviction state but live in another that requires me to register.

Out of the 700,000 offenders that are compliant it’s estimated 2.5% will re-offend and have the lowest Recidivism rate of all other crimes. Mandatory treatment and the registry help keep this rate low. I have helped police with other offenders and helped Children services spot a potential offender. A lot of us can actually help watch and keep a community safer.

That being said, I still would not want my property values to go down because I have several offenders living next to me, though I am not concerned about them. Kids are not safe these days and it’s the ones that have yet to go through the system and unknown that are dangerous. We don’t know who these folks are.

it’s a mixed issue for me, I live on both sides. Right now there are offenders everywhere and it’s getting to the point some are getting numb to it. informed people know that most are not dangerous, but what they don’t know is the few that may be. The states need to overhaul the system and remove from public (Not from registration) all but the ones that fit a dangerous profile. Someone that molested a family member is a far different type of offender than someone that abducted a child from a park.